The fact-checking organizations had a field day during & after the Republican convention, since so much lying and deceit characterized nearly every talk. Even Mrs. Mitt Romney, known by one and all as a pillar of rectitude, repeated the totally false canard about President Obama telling small business "you didn't build it." Just about the only ones who didn't lie to some degree or other were the families from Bishop Romney's ward and, just about, his former associate in his bishopric.
The rest lied, and lied, and then lied some more.
And Clint Eastwood made it clear that his imaginary guest on the stage, Barack Obama, was saying "Go f....ck yourself" repeatedly. This in front of the Romney clan's small children--not to mention any children in front of the TV when it aired during prime time.
Yet the next day Mrs. Mitt defended the skit, completely unfazed by 10 minutes of comic obscenity in front of her grandchildren.
If Clint had said the words out loud instead of implying them, the Republican National Committee would have been fined massively by the FCC.
More importantly, every single person connected to the Republican campaign has come out and dismissed all the fact-checking organizations as all being partisan lib-er-uls trying to get President Obama re-elected.
The very same organizations that call out the Obama campaign for its own lies and distortions daily.
And it sure works for partisan Republicans, whose knee-jerk rejection of all media outside the Fox/Rush orbit was abundantly clear in the comment threads of the major newspaper articles.
These guys show all the signs of being brainwashed cult devotees through their circle-the-wagons paranoia about the world outside the Republiverse.
----------------------
Footnote: the RNC convention talked repeatedly about our founding fathers and how we should get back to their beliefs and ideas.
The irony is that they're the liberals' founding fathers. The conservatives of that era were Tories who stood with the Crown. It's pretty funny that they talk so reverently about the people they were taking up arms against at the time...
Showing posts with label fact checking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fact checking. Show all posts
Friday, August 31, 2012
Friday, June 15, 2012
When a politician tells you exactly what you want to hear...
Yesterday Factcheck.org ran an article detailed some of the lie-tmotifs the Democrats and Republicans are saying about each other, over and over--in general describing the differences between the parties as being bigger than they are.
They aren't as big as the parties make them out to be because neither wants you to know how beholden both parties are to America's richest people, whose political purchasing power has been amped up massively by the Supreme Court's decision to let a billion bouquets of bucks bloom anonymously in each and every upcoming political campaign.
There's still a difference. True, Romney and Obama are both servicing the designed of the Masters of the Universe (neither Obama nor Bush had/have started criminal actions against any of the bankers and investors who kicked over the pillars of our economy).
However, Romney has skin in the game. If he wins, he will personally and hugely profit in his own personal taxes. And philosophically he's totally on board with the GOP's rich patrons. Obama does not have skin in the game--he would personally lose money in his own personal taxes if he got his way. And philosophically he's a pragmatist focused on the art of the possible, and in our money-dominated politics he's holding his nose and playing along with the billionaires as much as he must.
In 2008 this resulted in the billionaires apportioning their patronage between the GOP and the Democratic candidate. Now, in 2012, those who were hedging their bets by donating large amounts (by normal mortal standards) to both parties are now stiffing Obama and donating hugely to Romney.
So if Obama wins he won't be beholden to them, both because it'll be his last term, and because he won't have made the promises to them Romney will have.
This isn't a reason to worship Obama. He's a politician who's less seamy than Romney, is all. But it sure is a reason to vote for him.
It is not, however, a reason to believe everything he says. I check every major claim against Factcheck.org and Politifact.com, and you should too.
To quote the bottom line paragraph of yesterday's Factcheck.org article:
"Sensible voters can still decide elections – but they shouldn’t expect the unbiased truth from 30-second TV spots, or partisan talking points repeated endlessly on cable networks. But to be sensible, a voter must first ask, 'Does that claim sound too good – or too much like what I want to hear — to be true?' That’s where the search for the sometimes unwelcome truth begins."
– Brooks Jackson
They aren't as big as the parties make them out to be because neither wants you to know how beholden both parties are to America's richest people, whose political purchasing power has been amped up massively by the Supreme Court's decision to let a billion bouquets of bucks bloom anonymously in each and every upcoming political campaign.
There's still a difference. True, Romney and Obama are both servicing the designed of the Masters of the Universe (neither Obama nor Bush had/have started criminal actions against any of the bankers and investors who kicked over the pillars of our economy).
However, Romney has skin in the game. If he wins, he will personally and hugely profit in his own personal taxes. And philosophically he's totally on board with the GOP's rich patrons. Obama does not have skin in the game--he would personally lose money in his own personal taxes if he got his way. And philosophically he's a pragmatist focused on the art of the possible, and in our money-dominated politics he's holding his nose and playing along with the billionaires as much as he must.
In 2008 this resulted in the billionaires apportioning their patronage between the GOP and the Democratic candidate. Now, in 2012, those who were hedging their bets by donating large amounts (by normal mortal standards) to both parties are now stiffing Obama and donating hugely to Romney.
So if Obama wins he won't be beholden to them, both because it'll be his last term, and because he won't have made the promises to them Romney will have.
This isn't a reason to worship Obama. He's a politician who's less seamy than Romney, is all. But it sure is a reason to vote for him.
It is not, however, a reason to believe everything he says. I check every major claim against Factcheck.org and Politifact.com, and you should too.
To quote the bottom line paragraph of yesterday's Factcheck.org article:
"Sensible voters can still decide elections – but they shouldn’t expect the unbiased truth from 30-second TV spots, or partisan talking points repeated endlessly on cable networks. But to be sensible, a voter must first ask, 'Does that claim sound too good – or too much like what I want to hear — to be true?' That’s where the search for the sometimes unwelcome truth begins."
– Brooks Jackson
Thursday, September 15, 2011
Liars
The cleverest liars tell the truth--they just tell it in such as way as to get listeners to believe the lie they want you to believe.
This gives them "plausible deniability."
They do it by
1. removing context--omitting other truths--facts, reason--that would lead listeners to a different conclusion
2. trying to trigger powerful tribal fears and anger that lead listeners to an embattled "circle the wagons" mentality
3. exploiting people's inability to understand statistics (also known as innumeracy)
Examples are innumerable. A good way to find them is by going to factcheck.org or politifact.com and see where the liar didn't so much lie as pull the shenanigans I've described here.
You can't stop with simply checking the factuality of what is said. That the bottom line. You also have to make sure that the facts being cited are true in context, and aren't coupled with emotionally compelling narratives that lead listeners down the rabbit hole.
"Context disambiguates."
EDIT:
Perfect example this week. FOX TV saturated its coverage this week with a clip of President Obama saying "If you love me, pass this bill."
Well. What an egomaniac, huh?
Only problem is all those Fox viewers didn't get the context: Obama was giving an unscripted answer to someone in the town hall audience he was addressing, who shouted out "I love you!"
See? Without context: egomaniac; with context: clever off-the-cuff answer.
It's all about context. And the fact that clever propagandists don't hesistate to lie with the truth.
This gives them "plausible deniability."
They do it by
1. removing context--omitting other truths--facts, reason--that would lead listeners to a different conclusion
2. trying to trigger powerful tribal fears and anger that lead listeners to an embattled "circle the wagons" mentality
3. exploiting people's inability to understand statistics (also known as innumeracy)
Examples are innumerable. A good way to find them is by going to factcheck.org or politifact.com and see where the liar didn't so much lie as pull the shenanigans I've described here.
You can't stop with simply checking the factuality of what is said. That the bottom line. You also have to make sure that the facts being cited are true in context, and aren't coupled with emotionally compelling narratives that lead listeners down the rabbit hole.
"Context disambiguates."
EDIT:
Perfect example this week. FOX TV saturated its coverage this week with a clip of President Obama saying "If you love me, pass this bill."
Well. What an egomaniac, huh?
Only problem is all those Fox viewers didn't get the context: Obama was giving an unscripted answer to someone in the town hall audience he was addressing, who shouted out "I love you!"
See? Without context: egomaniac; with context: clever off-the-cuff answer.
It's all about context. And the fact that clever propagandists don't hesistate to lie with the truth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)